Exclusive: FAO Director sacked after Israeli diplomat filmed staff protest on Gaza

 ROME – A woman diplomat from the Israeli Embassy to the FAO filmed a silent staff protest against the use by the Israeli military of starvation in Gaza that was held inside FAO headquarters every Thursday, leading to director Ben Davis not having his contract at the UN agency renewed, FAO sources said. 

 Staff from the FAO had attended the silent weekly lunchtime protest in a courtyard over the past two years since the Israeli response to the Hamas Oct. 7 terrorist attacks began causing severe hunger among the Palestinian civilian population.

 The FAO published on its website a report on starvation in Gaza co-authored by Dr Davis, an American, but then cravenly removed it under pressure from Israel and the United States, the sources said.

 A veteran observer of the UN agency commented that £While this action from FAO is unfortunately not surprising, it is deeply disappointing and, in my view, more reflective of the type of management approach one would expect under an authoritarian system than within an organization of the United Nations.”

 “FAO has a long-standing practice of providing Directors and other D-level colleagues (D1/D2/ADG) with one-year contracts. The argument has historically been that this encourages senior leaders to perform and work harder because renewal is not automatic. In practice, I believe it has precisely the opposite effect.”

 “Rather than motivating people, it creates an environment of insecurity in which colleagues have the constant prospect of non-renewal hanging over them. Beyond the professional implications, it also has very real personal consequences. It is extremely difficult to establish any sense of financial normalcy when you are effectively living from one annual contract to the next. Obtaining mortgages, loans or other forms of credit becomes considerably more difficult when you cannot demonstrate reasonable continuity of employment.”

 The FAO watcher added: “More troubling, however, is the way this insecurity can be used to exercise authority and manage through fear. When the continuation of a senior leader's employment depends on an annual renewal decision, the message, whether explicit or implicit, is clear: conform to what senior management expects, or potentially place your own position at risk. That is not performance management; it creates a culture in which compliance and loyalty can become more important than independent judgment, constructive challenge or principled leadership.”

 “The example of staff relations is particularly telling. If the Staff Association organizes a walkout and asks colleagues to wear orange in solidarity, Directors understand very clearly that they had better not be seen wearing orange. Such a gesture risks being interpreted by the DG and others not simply as solidarity with staff, but as a senior leader taking sides and failing to conform with the position expected by senior management.”

 “When even something as innocuous as wearing a particular colour requires a Director to consider whether it might affect their next contract renewal, there is something fundamentally wrong with the organizational culture. That is exercising authority through insecurity and managing by fear.”

 “Senior leaders should be able to exercise independent judgment, respectfully challenge decisions and demonstrate solidarity with staff without having to calculate whether doing so could jeopardize their employment. Indeed, those are characteristics we should expect from senior leadership, not behaviours that people should feel compelled to suppress.”

 “How practices and behaviours of this nature continue to be tolerated and accepted is beyond me, particularly when Member States are fully aware of the dynamics involved. Whatever rationale may originally have been offered for annual D-level contracts, a system that can be used to reinforce conformity, discourage independent leadership and manage people through fear deserves serious scrutiny rather than continued acceptance as normal management practice.”

 During a farewell speech to his division staff, Davis quipped to applause that before departing FAO he had inadvertently fulfilled one last ambition -- to have an article about himself published in the Italian Insider. 

 

 © COPYRIGHT ITALIAN INSIDER
UNAUTHORISED REPRODUCTION FORBIDDEN